What happens if you eat a sprouted potato?

Eating small amounts of sprouts is unlikely to cause harm, but large amounts can cause solanine poisoning with symptoms including nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, stomach cramps, and headache. Always remove sprouts before eating.

Is It Safe to Eat Sprouted Potatoes?

Q: Is it safe to eat sprouted potatoes?

Yes, sprouted potatoes are safe to eat if the sprouts are small (under 1 inch) and the potato is still firm. Remove all sprouts and eyes completely, cutting at least 1/2 inch around them. However, if sprouts are long, the potato is soft, wrinkled, or has green skin, throw it away as solanine levels may be too high.

Q: Can you eat potatoes with eyes?

Yes, potatoes with small eyes are safe to eat. Simply cut out the eyes and any sprouts, removing about 1/2 inch of potato around each eye. The rest of the potato is fine to cook and eat.

Quick Answer: Yes, if the sprouts are small and the potato is firm. Cut out all sprouts and eyes, plus ½ inch around them. If the potato is soft, wrinkled, or very green — throw it away.

When Sprouted Potatoes Are Safe

✓ Safe to eat when:

Sprouts are small (under 1 inch)
Potato is still firm when squeezed
No green color under the skin
No wrinkled or shriveled skin

Simply cut out all the sprouts and "eyes" (the small indentations where sprouts grow), removing about ½ inch of potato around each one. The rest of the potato is perfectly fine to cook and eat.

When to Throw Them Away

✗ Throw away when:

Sprouts are long (over 1-2 inches)
Potato feels soft or squishy
Skin is wrinkled or shriveled
Green color visible on skin or flesh
Bitter taste when cooked

Why Do Sprouted Potatoes Matter?

Potatoes produce a natural toxin called solanine (a glycoalkaloid) when they sprout, turn green, or are damaged. Solanine is concentrated in the sprouts, eyes, and green parts.

In small amounts, solanine isn't harmful. But in larger amounts, it can cause:

Nausea and vomiting
Diarrhea and stomach cramps
Headache
In rare severe cases: fever, confusion

The good news: you'd need to eat a significant amount of sprouts to get sick. Removing them makes the potato safe.

Can You Eat Potatoes with Eyes?

Yes. "Eyes" are just the spots where sprouts will eventually grow. If there are no actual sprouts yet, simply cut out the eyes and cook normally. Even small sprouts emerging from eyes are fine — just remove them completely.

How to Prevent Potatoes from Sprouting

Store in a cool, dark place (45-50°F is ideal)
Keep away from onions — they release gases that speed sprouting
Don't refrigerate — too cold converts starch to sugar
Use within 2-3 weeks of purchase
Keep in a paper bag — allows airflow while blocking light

The Bottom Line

Sprouted potatoes are safe to eat as long as you remove all sprouts and the potato is still firm. When in doubt, trust your senses: if it's soft, wrinkled, green, or smells off, throw it out. Potatoes are cheap — your health isn't.

Got a specific question about your potatoes?

Describe what you're seeing and get personalized advice.

Ask ShouldI.today →

AI-generated content for informational purposes. When in doubt about food safety, trust your senses or throw it out.